Last season the Giants gave their fans the thrill of a lifetime by capturing the franchise’s first World Championship since its arrival in San Francisco in 1958. The victory parade on Market Street drew a crowd estimated at nearly 1,000,000 people. Fans celebrated The Freak, The Beard, The Panda, and Aubrey Huff’s rally thong.
This year The Freak had a losing record, The Beard hurt his arm, The Panda broke his hand, and the rally thong lost its magic as its owner suffered through arguably his worst season and may force the Giants to face the fact that they spent $23 million on a player whose skills have dissipated at age 34.
The fans, though, performed like champions. All 81 games at AT&T Park were sellouts and the team set an all time attendance record of nearly 3.4 million tickets sold. Even though many of the games were low-scoring snoozers, those at the ballpark remained engaged, loud and hopeful, pretty much until the bitter end.
How did things end so badly for the 2011 Giants? Partly it was the law of averages. Players like Huff, Pat Burrell and Cody Ross got hot at precisely the right time in 2010 to help carry an offense that many considered suspect. Each of those players thudded back to earth this season, and Burrell is suffering from a degenerative foot condition that might end his career. Andres Torres may have proved that career minor leaguers who suddenly have great years in the big leagues past age 30 are unlikely to repeat such a performance, and supporting contributors like Juan Uribe and Edgar Renteria who did not return turned out to be sorely missed.
Mostly, though, the downfall of the 2011 Giants could be centered on two key injuries in a three week span. On May 25, Florida Marlins outfielder (and Northern California native) Scott Cousins leveled Giants catcher and reigning National League Rookie of the Year Buster Posey while scoring the winning run in an extra inning game. In the act of blocking the plate, Posey’s left leg was trapped under his 220-pound body leading to torn ligaments and broken bones in his left ankle. He missed the remainder of the season. Sixteen nights later former NL Batting Champion, second baseman Freddy Sanchez, dislocated his shoulder diving for a ground ball, and was also out for the rest of this season.
The Giant offense never recovered. Their total of 570 runs was 29th out of 30 major league teams. The only reason the Giants were able to win 86 games and remain marginally in contention until their last road trip was that their pitching staff was second-best in the National League. Unfortunately, even great pitching cannot overcome an offense that scores one run or fewer in 36 games.
Losing Posey was the biggest blow. Catcher is the most difficult position to fill in a daily lineup, and catchers who contribute significantly with the bat are rare. In 2010 Posey finished 11th in the MVP voting even though he was not called up to the majors until May. In one instant this season the Giants lost a player who figured to contribute 25 homers, perhaps 90 or more RBIs and hit close to .300 while holding down a key defensive position. Posey’s replacements hit less than .200, managed just seven homeruns, and turned a position of great strength into a significant weakness on defense as well as with the bat.
Giant manager Bruce Bochy said taking Posey out of the Giant lineup was, “like taking Johnny Bench out of the Big Red Machine … for us he was that important.”
Giants’ fans have reason to be optimistic for next season. Posey is recovering well from his injury and is expected to be 100 per cent by spring training. The starting rotation should return intact and because of the team’s success at the box office there is plenty of money in the coffers to add a couple of key bats to the lineup. The sentimental loyalty that often comes from winning the World Series won’t be a factor in constructing next season’s roster, and, perhaps most important, the Giants do not have a dominant opponent within their division that can be counted on to win year after year.
As you read this, pitchers and catchers report in about 90 days. In the meantime, it will be fun to watch the Giants rebuild their roster this winter and attempt to get back on top of the baseball world.